November 15, 2009

ModWright Arrives At Centre Circle Audio

Centre Circle Audio has acquired the agency for ModWright Instruments' line of electronics.

ModWright, founded in 2000, started life as popular and reputable modifier for a number of digital players. As time goes, it has built up a line of amplification products too, consisting of preamps, power amps and a phono stage.

Their first batch of products, consisting of a pre-power amp combo, has arrived at Centre Circle Audio and are ready for audition.
The LS36.5 is a tube linestage (2 6H30 Russian Super Tubes and 1 5AR4 rectifier) and comes with a host of features and conveniences including XLR inputs and outputs, remote control, home theatre bypass and a phase switch. It can be upgraded further with an external dual-mono power supply, also tubed, called the PS36.5. The LS36.5 comes in at 27lbs (12kg).
The KWA150 power amp is a purely solid state affair, but ModWright says that it combines both the virtues of tube and solid state products, The KWA150 gives out 150w @8ohms, 250w @4ohms - and wait for this - it can be bridged for 450w @8ohms and 650w @4ohms, all rated at 0.05% THD. Weight is a back breaking 84lbs (38kg).

The KWA150 has both single-ended and balanced inputs, and has a special feature for the user to choose high or low bias current - ModWright did not specify how many watts of class A power the KWA150 will put out at each bias setting, but when I was at Centre Circle Audio yesterday, the KWA150 was set at high bias and it was running much hotter than my 60watt class A Pass Labs.

A friend and me had a very brief listen with the ModWright combo driving Thiel 3.7 loudspeakers, the frontend was the eminently musical Pathos Endorphin CD player. It was a very good first impression - the KWA150 had no problem driving the Thiel, the sound was extended and very open, the soundstage was dimensional and big. There was a lot of musical details, everything was presented clearly and without brightness, even though the amps were out of their boxes for just a couple of days.

Prices are yet to be fixed. Go and take a listen at Centre Circle Audio!

Contact Centre Circle Audio, Ph: 03-77282686; Nelson Chia 012-2876807; Sky Wong 012-3371787

Marantz CD7 Takes A Break, Copland CDA-822 To The Rescue.

My beloved Marantz CD7 takes break, not for too long, I hope.
Yes, my dear readers, the inevitable just happened and sooner than I had expected too. The transport and tracking laser assembly of my beloved work horse CDP, Marantz CD7 has given up the ghost! After more than 8 years of faithful service, it's decided to call it a day.

Most of my friends have been encouraging me to change or see an upgrade opportunity, and a group just suggested to me that it's time to give up on CD, and move on to music servers. There's 2 reasons why I need to restore the CD player to it's original working condition.

1) Whilst waiting for music servers to mature in terms of user interface and sound quality, I still need to rely on a CD player until the day I decide to take the music server route to hifi dom.

2) I really love the Marantz CD7 dearly for it's magical sound, and for all that I know, a relic of it's kind, the last and quite possibly, the best of the 16 bit machines. I am sentimentally attached to it too.

So if any one here reading can be so helpful to point me to contacts where I can get a complete Philips VAM1252 transport assembly, I'd appreciate your help very much.
I've tried many places and none can help me to source for one so far. And don't ask me to go to the local Malaysian Marantz distributor just yet. I've asked them and they are trying to help. I am still hoping they'll try harder.

In the mean time, the excellent Copland CDA-822 is called in to service, courtesy of Odiosleuth. Thanks man!
In the mean time, my dearest partner in crime, Odiosleuth as kind as ever, offered me the services of his standby CDP, the Copland CDA-822. So from here onwards, until the full restoration of the Marantz, all reviews will be covered with the Copland as the source. Sound wise, the Copland is just as musical as the Marantz, if it digs out even just very slightly more information from those antiquated 5 inch disc. The Copland does not have as low a noise floor as the current crop of top grade CD spinners. However, just like the Marantz, it was a truly formidable CD player for it's time.

In case you've missed out my plea earlier, please let me know if you've got contacts to source for the complete Philips VAM1252 transport assembly. Thanks for reading.

November 11, 2009

Wonder Wood? - Cardas Golden Cuboid


The Cardas Golden Cuboid is an unassuming looking piece of rectangular solid wood. Its only distinguishing mark is the Cardas nautilus logo engraved on it. It comes in 2 sizes - 0.618"x1" x 1.618" and 1" x 1.618" x 2.618" (I'll just call them 'small' and 'big'). Those in the know will instantly recognize the golden ratio applied in the measurements immediately, i.e., 1 to1.618 (read wikipedia for more on the golden ratio if you are interested).

The big & small Golden Cuboids contrasted for size with a ballpoint pen

Cardas' advocacy is that the golden ratio dampens resonance. In fact it also advocates speaker placement and hifi room dimensions based on the golden ratio, you can read more on their website. The Cardas Golden Cuboid is made from myrtle wood, a rare American hardwood according to Cardas. Ayre also offers their own version, apparently sourced from Cardas too.

Now, I believe some of you who see the picture of these wood blocks would think, "Why should I pay for them, I can fashion them myself." Hmmm... that should be interesting, I wonder too whether wood blocks made from local hardwood such as chengal would have a similar or better effect than myrtle. However, I am the lazy kind, at RM32 per piece for the big Golden Cuboid and RM23 for the small one , I would spend my leisure time listening to music rather than on wood cutting. I tried my hands many years ago trying to saw chengal for some diy carpentry, it was no walk in the park really, I gave up. :-) However, some might want to apply the dimensions to, say, mdf, which is easy to work with, I'd love to hear your result here.

These myrtle wood blocks are to be used as support, like cones, under your components, three as a set. Do they have any effect in my system? Yes, certainly. I'll describe it later. The effect of the Cardas Golden Cuboids is, let's say, not day and night in my system, though clearly discernible and, more importantly, musically significant. Please keep this in mind when you read on, I'd suggest you add the word 'slightly' in front of my every description of their sonic effects. :-)

I also wonder whether my finite elemente signature rack has reduced much of the resonance problem in my system, such that the myrtle blocks have less to do, so this may very much be a 'you mileage may vary' kind of scenario.

I first tried a trio of the small ones under my Ayre C-5xeMP universal player. On first listen, I blurted out a disbelieving 'huh?'. After a few more tracks, a quite surprised 'wow' (ok, this is a 'wow', not a 'WOW', but it is a wow nonetheless :-) ). The sound became calmer and more stable, the images better defined. I could hear more low level details in the music, more pronounced were the nuances in vocals - breathing, control, vibrato, etc.. I was listening to my favourite tracks, 'Shenandoah' and 'India Song', from Youn Sun Nah's album "Voyage", I got pulled into the music more readily than before and there were more toe curling moments. It worked also on 'bigger' music - with the Chinese drum troupe track "Poem for Chinese drum" from Hugo's "The Dreams of Chinese Butterfly" CD, the drum beats were more solidly felt, and the atmosphere was also more readily apparent.

Cardas Golden Cuboid under the Ayre C-5xeMP

I was a skeptic, but I am now sold. I was thinking why should a RM26k player need a few wood blocks to improve its performance. Well, I don't know, but for the price of the small Cardas Golden Cuboids, I am not going to complain too loudly. I think the performance on their equipment is what gotten Ayre into having their own myrtle wood blocks too. I still need to emphasize that the effect was not night and day, like I said earlier, but it was an improvement significant enough to me personally. And for that kind of price, I think they are punching way above their weight.

After longer listening over a few days, during which I took them out and put them back twice, I still liked what I heard, so there they shall stay under the Ayre.

Over time I got a better understanding of the effect of the Cardas Golden Cuboids. They seem to also take away some brightness or some shine from the highs, you can look at it either way, depending on your existing system balance. There may also be a slight lift on the mid-bass. See whether such characteristics would benefit you. But be a little careful if your system is already on the warmish or slightly dark side. If you have some brightness in your system that you need to cure, I think you should definitely check out the Cardas Golden Cuboids.

For my next experiment, I moved to my Shunyata Hydra 8 powerline conditioner. Putting a trio of the small Golden Cuboids under it did not seem to have any effect. It could be that the Hydra 8 was sitting on the bottom shelf of my finite elemente rack, an already hefty chunk of solid wood, which is also sitting on 4 pieces of finite elemente cerapuc. Or possibly too that the Hydra 8 was a passive component, so it was less affected by resonance.

Then, I wanted to try the big Cardas Golden Cuboids under my monoblocks, but their chassis were raised too tall by the feet to fit the big cuboids under. I could lay the blocks on their sides instead of laying them flat to lift the monoblocks, but thought against it. It would not be stable and I was afraid the monoblocks would come 'crashing down' on the floor. :-)

So, instead, I decided to swap the small Golden Cuboids under the Ayre with the big ones. Well, there was a difference. The effects I described with the small Golden Cuboids were still there, and now there was an even more enhanced sense of control and stability to the sound. For my personal taste, I preferred the slightly more lively presentation with the small Golden Cuboids. However, this result showed that the big Golden Cuboids had a greater effect, if your system needed greater resonance control, the big ones might be a better bet.

The last item left for me now was to try the Golden Cuboids on my pre-amp. My Pass Labs X2.5 was sitting on 3 finite elemente Ceraballs, which were more than 5 times dearer than the Cardas Golden Cuboids. I liked the Ceraballs' effects on the X2.5, they opened up the sound, rendered a bigger soundstage and improved focus and resolution, music flowed better too. Changing the Ceraballs to Golden Cuboids pulled the sound the other direction, it became slightly more warmish, soundstage was less grand but felt more intimate, resolution was not as good though. However, comparing the Cardas Golden Cuboids underneath or having the pre-amp sitting directly on the rack, I still preferred to have the Cuboids under the pre-amp.

finite elemente Ceraballs and the small Cardas Golden Cuboids

Horses for courses, these results seem to show. I tried the Ceraballs on the Ayre player before the Cardas Golden Cuboids came. The Ceraballs expanded the soundstage and sharpened the imaging, but I lost some solidity in the sound, it became slightly diffused. So I preferred to have the Ayre placed directly on the rack. When the Golden Cuboids came along, I preferred to have the Ayre put on top of them. Whereas with the Pass Labs pre-amp I much preferred the Ceraballs to the Golden Cuboids.

I said before that tweaks to me are like flavourings in cooking, like a dab of soy sauce in your porridge, or a pinch of salt in your stir fry. Without them, you may not get the right flavour, the key is to use the right kind and the right amount.

On Cardas' website, they also showed notched version of the Golden Cuboids, these are meant as cable lifters (to lift your cables off the floor), Hi-Way Laser did not bring in the cable-lifter version, but these wood blocks could conceivably be used for this purpose too (which offers a cheaper alternative to Shunyata's Darkfield that I am using). I did not have the time to check it out, but you can.

The Cardas Golden Cuboids aren't that expensive, you can get a pack of six in a nice black velvet pouch and share the fun with your hifi buddies! I am keeping them myself. :-)

Cardas is available from Hi-Way Laser. Contact Kenny 03-7873.8325; 019-281.3399 .

November 8, 2009

How To Make HiFi Reviews Work For You.

My current subscription only mag.

How many times have you heard people whom put together a hifi system comprising of all 5 star rated equipment, only to complain that the sonic result suck big time? Then bitterness set in and they start going around telling other people that "all reviews suck", "reviewers are all big fat liars", "hifi reviews cannot be trusted" and last, but not least "reviewers are better writers than they are listeners!". How about that person whom bought all the best and most expensive equipment that money can buy, only to find out that the resulting sound is not what they had expected? Well at least that last one had nothing to do with reviews. He!,He!

With this note I wish to give some insight about why the above scenarios happened. First I want to reinforce an advise that an ol' timer gave me recently. He told me that the 4 most important factors for putting together a successful hifi system is as follows in the order of priority:

1) The room - One have to first figure out where he intends to set up his hifi system. Because the room will always be a limiting factor to the speaker size it can accommodate, it'll also ultimately dictate if you'll end up with a big or smaller system. This is by logic that a big room will be able to accommodate a pair of big speakers. Big speakers need big amps. and after all the money you've plonk in to the both the former items, one will certainly not want to short change their performance by using less than equally good pre-amp and source equipment.

2) The power supply - Many ol' timers advocate a dedicated power supply line to your chosen room. But these days, a high quality power conditioner is a more convenient, if costly option. The quality of power supply will determine the level of performance of an audio system. All the best and most expensive hifi gear will not perform at their full potential if power supply is not taken care of.

3) The person - The person putting together a system is responsible for the outcome of the final sonic result. No one else shall be blamed for the mess he got himself in to. The person selects all the equipment, either thru reviews or friend's recommendation or just any other reason one can think of under the sun. The most important thing is to listen to the hifi equipment before buying, no matter how many 5 star reviews, awards or how many friends recommended it. I have to ask this question, do you know the test conditions(a.k.a. the listening room), preference of the reviewers writing the review or awarding the awards? How about your friends preferences? Does he like the same things that you do in sound reproduction? And finally, the system owner must ultimately set up, tweak and do all one could to ensure the system that he has painstakingly put together works optimally and results in great sound. Knowledge, effort and time is key to getting a system to sound good.

4) Equipment - Many people say brand A suck, brand B no good, brand C not his cuppa tea! With so many equipments available to choose from, the choice can appear to be daunting. But with enough patience and perseverance, I am very sure one can find the equipment that he likes. Most modern high end hifi equipment offered by the major brands are tonally neutral with minimal coloration, highly transparent, have wide dynamic range and ultra wide frequency bandwidth. On top of that, most offer great reliability and excellent user flexibilities to various degrees. When some say brand A suck, maybe it just doesn't match the system synergy, maybe the system it self is not transparent enough reveal the strengths of product brand A? The hifi system's performance is only as strong as it's weakest link, remember? Did you also note that equipment is ranked the lowest amongst the 4 factors?


With the above 4 main factors explained, I now move on to the thorny issues of the reviewers them selves. Who are they?

Reviewers, are just basically, people like us! People who like music and are intrigue at the way each different hifi equipment portrays the music, and they all do it differently so. All I can say is writing about hifi requires a certain amount of passion, unlike a journalist writing about an event to be printed on the news paper. A Singaporean forumer posted in an online hifi forum that these days, any one with a set of half decent hifi and access to internet can call them selves reviewers! I totally agree to that statement. He!He! We have quite a few examples here don't we?

Car mags are just like hifi mags, only the subject is different, but why no brick bats about the test drivers/writers here?

Hifi mags are very much like car mags, the reviewers/test drivers write about a subject they have passion for. However, we must also remember, that reviewers are just like us, only human. They all have their preferences, which dictates the final sound of their reference system, which is again like us, their hifi set up is dictated by the above 4 main factors, i.e. room size, power supply, the person himself and finally the equipment that he uses as references! See how things goes around, comes back in another round?

However, all said and done, the hifi reviewers have one certain clear advantage that most of us don't. Just like the test drivers whom write car mags, hifi reviewers get to play with a wide variety of gears that most of us average audiophile can only dream of. It's the experiences of various products at various price points and the comparable experience can be used to make recommendations based on one's subjective preference against the over all product standards within the industry. Just like the test drivers of the various car mags, for example: Honda Accord, Toyota Camry, Mazda 6 or Hyundai Azeera? All belong within the corporate/executive car price bracket, but which is best? Now, I am gonna put on my amateur test driver cap here as an example:

The sportiest road feel with responsive engine: Mazda 6, followed closely by the Honda Accord.

The most comfy ride with high refinement: Toyota Camry, followed by Hyundai Azeera, Honda Accord, and lastly Mazda 6

The most spacious accommodation: Toyota Camry, Hyundai Azeera, and a joint third placing shared by both the Honda Accord and the Mazda 6.
These are just the subjective part of the product's interaction with us, the drivers.


Other more technical factors, which can be measured by specifications like 0-60 times, top speed, vehicle dimensions, no. of cylinders, engine config, compression ratio and fuel economy are all printed on the brochures, so no disputes there. Are there any bad cars of the 4? No, all are just products that each different manufacturer can do within a price point. Compromises are made, some towards a sportier theme, but less accommodating. Some push towards the plush refined side of the spectrum, while others trying to juggle between the two extremes. In the end, what sways buyer A to a Toyota Camry or buyer B to a Honda Accord, ultimately boils down to preference of the individual. Now does it matter if most of the test drivers in the various car mags prefer the Mazda 6? In fact, the Mazda 6 series has won more design achievement awards then the other 3 cars compared here, but where is it in the context of the Malaysian market place? What does that say about the preferences of the Malaysian drivers?

Just like cars, hifi equipment also has 2 sides to it's performance parameters. The subjective interactive user experience part and the latter part of technical specs which are measurable. The second part is the easy part as it can give us an idea about the equipment's performance potential. The important thing is the subjective part, i.e. practical realization the equipment's potential in the context of our system. Again just to add to the subjective vs objective camp debate, in cars, I've driven cars that felt like they going faster than they actually are, like the Alfa Romeo 156 2.0 Selespeed, it doesn't go any faster than, say a equivalent Camry 2.2 of the same vintage year, but it just felt like it went faster, with the sportier theme and engine/exhaust note. However, the stop watch doesn't lie. Bringing back the same debate in hifi, why does some poorer measuring equipment sound better than another superior measured/better spec model? I do not have an answer to either the subjective experience vs objective performance of cars or hifi just yet. Perhaps a day will come when we're all enlighten enough.

Just like how our choice of cars to fit our lifestyle and image, hifi purchase decisions are more or less effect by the same emotional choice. Now why don't I hear people calling car test drivers liars or other derogatory remarks?

So let's assume that all the hifi reviews that we read, does actually reflect the reality of the equipment's subjective sonic capabilities, i.e. reviewers are not lying. Then the only way of trusting reviewers verdict on the review subject is to get to know them, just like we get to know a friend. Let us take reviewers from Stereophile, which I read regularly and have by now formed my opinion about the reviewers that write there. I here by summarise what I think of the following reviewers:

Sam Tellig: Reviews mostly boutique European manufacturers stuff. Loves smaller sized, budget and sometimes China made hifi equipment. I can gather that he is fond of Harbeth, Triangle speakers and Lavardin, Creek and a few other flea watt brands of amplifiers. Most of the stuff he likes, though I have no objections, but just not really my cuppa tea.He!He!

Art Dudley: Loves mostly English and boutique/cottage Japanese hifi gears. His reference system consist of a Sony 777xes SACD player, a modified Linn LP12 turntable, Shindo amps. I am not quite sure what speakers he is using now, but I am sure he like to use transformer based phono stages. I can mostly agree with his reviews on sources only.

Micheal Fremer: The ultra high end guy in Stereophile. Most of the stuff he reviews, I can't afford! But I could agree with many of his reviews.

John Atkinson: Stereophile Editor in Chief and Test Bench guy. He seems to like gears of absolute neutrality, as reflect by his choice of Mark Levinson, Sim Audio amps and Revel speakers. I can only say that I love beautiful sound over absolute neutrality. He is also a music downloads guy. Computer hifi, is not for me just yet. However, I do find John's comments on the test bench results reflective of the design and circuit quality, which is helpful for me from a technical point of view.

Wes Philips: I have found my self to be able to relate to many of his reviews, and he is normally not far off the mark from my very own experiences with the hifi equipments that he reviews. He mostly reviews gears of similar quality and price levels as those "featured" here in HiFi Unlimited, may be that's why?


So now you know what I mean by getting to know the reviewers. By getting to know the people whom write the reviews, we can gauge their preferences, mostly in which review samples they bought. Just like us, Big E and Odiosleuth. We can all like the things we review, but we'll only buy them if we like them too much, not able live without them!(unless, we can't afford them that is). Now is that practical logic or what? But the question remains still, do you like the same things that we do in sound reproduction? How well do you know us as friends?

A good British read on mostly mid fi and entry level high end audio gear.

Lastly, speaker reviews are a little more tricky to decipher. However, I have an almost(yeah "almost" but not absolute!) way to sort them as well. My general take is this, if you have big space/room to put your hifi in to, then most American reviews of the speaker model you choose would be quite valid. If you've got a small room like mine, then most European reviews of the said speaker model is more valid. This is based on my opinion formed that most average American homes are bigger than most average European homes. And with big homes comes big rooms, smaller homes, you get equally small rooms. I also must point out that many American homes have rather flexible wooden build, but Europeans would almost certainly build their homes with stone, just like our Asian brick walls. This is because flexible wooden walls will easily cancel out some low bass quantity, and hard stone/brick wall will enhance low bass quantity to a certain degree. That's why it's common to have room boom for stone/brick wall rooms and almost a non issue with wooden built wall rooms. Now if a speaker review does mention about the room's size used for the said review, that's certainly a great plus, just to be very sure.

The British high end audio bible, I love reading Roy Gregory articles.

By now, I hope I've shed some light on how to use hifi reviews for the benefit of one's hifi audition short listings. DO NOT BUY any piece of hifi equipment on the strength of it's reviews. One should instead use reviews to shortlist the equipment candidates he wishes to purchase for audition. I think it is fair to short list 2 brands of specific hifi equipment within your budgeted spending range, 3 if you're rather fussy or harder working but I think to audition everything under the sun is just too time consuming and ultimately, only leads to frustration of having too many choices to confuse you.

I am not writing this to defend the hifi reviewers, I just think that it's a point that needs to be straighten and we can all enjoy reading our hifi mags again, with the full benefit of doubt as a courtesy to the professional reviewers at work.

November 7, 2009

New EgglestonWorks Loudspeakers Launch at Centre Circle Audio

Centre Circle Audio is planning a number of new product launches. Things will sure come fast and furious in the coming weeks.

The first batch of new products expected to arrive next week are the new EgglestonWorks loudspeaker models - the iconic Andra, now in mkIII guise and the new Dianne floorstander.

Centre Circle Audio is offering special launching prices for these 2 models in November and December 2009.

The Andra III
Frequency Response: -3dB at 18Hz to well beyond 24kHz
Efficiency: 88dB
Impedance: 8 ohms nominal, 6 ohms average
Footprint: 15" X 18" Height: 44"
Weght: 220 pounds per speaker

List Price: RM92,500 / Special Launching Price: RM60,999

The Dianne
Frequency Response: -3dB at 51Hz to well beyond 24kHz
Efficiency: 88dB
Impedance: 8 ohms nominal, 6 ohms minimum
Footprint: 8.5" X 12" Height: 41"
Weght: 55 pounds per speaker
List Price: RM12,000 / Special Launching Price: RM8,900

Contact Centre Circle Audio, Ph: 03-77282686; Nelson Chia 012-2876807; Sky Wong 012-3371787